the spectrum, honestly, which is why Jeff Anderson's book,
One conclusion I've taken away even from the first chapter of Mechanically Inclined, though, has been that teaching grammar and mechanics has to be a balance between teaching a grammar lesson singularly...and teaching grammar as a side-bar to whatever else we're teaching. Basically, it's possible to teach grammar and mechanics both in context and workshop-style. Anderson gives a list of ways to do this. I've simplified it a little bit:
- Using the shortest mentor text possible
- Teaching one thing at a time and applying it to our daily writing
- Adding quick daily doses of grammar and mechanics experiences with short mentor texts and editing
- Providing rich experiences in the writer's notebook to play with mentor sentences
Why Teachers Need This
One thing that really caught my eye in the beginning of Anderson's Mechanically Inclined was why he thought he had to write this book. He cites that our generation of teachers doesn't feel confident about teaching grammar and mechanics, and he's SO right. Sometimes, I feel insecure about my abilities to teach grammar and mechanics because sometimes I feel like I should know more. I often think, Oh my goodness -- I need to take a class on this stuff...
But Anderson makes me feel a little better about this. He says that grammar and mechanics is a "creational facility rather than a correctional one". And one thing I've come to learn about myself is that I am a great writer, and in turn, a great creator, so I know I can help my students do this and see it this way.
Hey Chelsea[Anderson's reason for writing this book is the same reason I assign it to my methods students. So many teachers do not feel confident about teaching grammar, even if they are really good writers. Writing and teaching others to write are two different challenges! I hope having a hand book like this with suggestions helps provide some ideas and strategies to combat that lack of confidence :)
ReplyDelete